A hefty and detailed piece of history, Kim Field’s book
methodically and almost obsessively catalogues the genres and influences of all
the famous harmonica players.
So many anecdotes, suppositions and conclusions, I found
myself highlighting text and note writing all over this book. Field throws so
many ideas and observations into the text that the book deserves more than one
reading.
To give one example; Field expands on the idea of how the slurred
chordal deliberate ‘mistakes’ made by the blues harmonica players relates to
west African music where such qualities are admired; the perfect smooth notes
are thought of as too sterile, lacking in expression. It’s a good point – to me
it ranks alongside something I read recently about Little Walter’s harmonica
style being close to a kind of Deep South New Orleans Cajun, Zydeco accordion
playing - interesting.
I’m afraid I just couldn't warm towards Larry Adler or
any of the ‘popularisers’ of the harmonica, it doesn't get me reaching for a
chromatic harmonica in any kind of hurry. The novelty acts and harmonica troupes
of the 1940’s and 50’s also made me feel slightly queasy, something a touch too
desperate about these acts, earnestly wanting to be accepted as serious
musicians, forever the poor relation.
I had a certain sympathy with the Jazz
harmonica players. Won’t say they were welcomed with open
arms by the Jazz fraternity but they were allowed to make their mark.
In all a book worth reading (and re-reading).